Remove race-based policies from public services
Pitched as a return to "one person, one vote, and the same rules for everyone," ACT wants ethnicity removed as a factor in how the state funds and delivers public services, putting need ahead of race or Treaty status.
The Policy: ACT Equal Rights and Democracy — 2023 Election →
_Neutrality note: this is a constitutionally contested area. The positions below are attributed to the people who hold them; figures are sourced; the entry takes no side on the underlying debate._
What it does:
- ACT's platform commits to "eliminate race-based policies across all areas of Government" and to challenge arrangements it says divide New Zealanders by ethnicity, alongside a push to "define the Treaty principles" and end co-governance in resource management and local services.
- In office as a coalition partner, ACT secured a Cabinet Office circular — announced by Public Service Minister Nicola Willis on 13 September 2024 — directing agencies to base targeting "on the needs of all New Zealanders" and to make a "strong analytical case" before using ethnicity as a proxy for need.
- The same package scrapped Labour's progressive procurement target that asked agencies to direct 8% of contracts to Maori-owned businesses, replacing it with a "public value" test.
- As Associate Health Minister, David Seymour instructed Pharmac in July 2024 to stop weighting the Treaty of Waitangi in funding decisions; Pharmac later disestablished its Maori advisory group.
- Related coalition moves ACT counts toward the same goal: the Maori Health Authority Te Aka Whai Ora was disestablished on 30 June 2024, and section 7AA of the Oranga Tamariki Act was repealed so that, in the Government's words, "child wellbeing" rather than whakapapa drives care decisions.
- Bowel-cancer screening was lowered to age 58 for everyone using money that had funded an earlier start age of 50 for Maori and Pacific people — which ACT lists as ending a race-based eligibility rule.
The result: Many individual pieces have been delivered, but ACT's stated end-goal — removing race-based criteria "across all areas of Government" — remains a continuing agenda rather than a finished one, so the overall pledge sits in progress. ACT leader David Seymour argues the state should serve people "based on actual need, without assigning their background as a proxy of need," and Nicola Willis frames the circular as fair, evidence-led targeting. Critics dispute both the premise and the process. Labour health spokesperson Dr Ayesha Verrall says decades of data show ethnicity is itself a real driver of unequal access; Green MP Francisco Hernandez called the public-service directive a "dog-whistle"; and Te Pati Maori co-leader Debbie Ngarewa-Packer argued need and ethnicity are inseparable for Maori and Pacific communities. The Waitangi Tribunal found the section 7AA repeal "rushed and arbitrary" with a "significant risk of actual harm." On bowel screening, Dr Nina Scott of Maori cancer network Hei Ahuru Mowai called raising the start age for Maori and Pacific people a form of "institutionalised racism," while the Ministry of Health argued the universal age-58 setting would prevent more cancers overall.
The impacts to watch:
- Whether removing ethnicity-targeted programmes narrows or widens documented health gaps — Pacific people face a 63% higher bowel-cancer mortality rate than non-Maori non-Pacific New Zealanders, and around 30% of bowel cancers in Maori women occur before age 50.
- Legal and Tiriti exposure: the Waitangi Tribunal has already ruled against parts of the agenda, and further claims or judicial review are possible as more changes land.
- How far the "need, not race" test reshapes everyday agency practice, given the circular still allows ethnicity-based targeting where a strong evidence case exists.
- Whether the broader, unlegislated commitments — defining the Treaty principles and ending co-governance — advance, stall, or are dropped as coalition priorities shift toward the 2026 election.
This overview is summarised by AI from public sources. It may contain errors and is a guide, not the definitive record — we welcome corrections.
Where our research raises a question the policy doesn't answer, we put it to you — these are our questions, not government policy. Your vote stays anonymous even when you sign up (we use sign-up only to send you more things to vote on that you care about), and we report aggregated results only — the country's sentiment, never how any individual voted.
Key milestones
ACT sets out "equal rights" platform
ACT campaigns on eliminating what it calls race-based policies "across all areas of Government," defining the Treaty principles in legislation, and ending co-governance in resource management and local services. The party frames it as "one person, one vote, and the same rules for everyone."
Waitangi Tribunal slams 7AA repeal
Among the coalition changes ACT counts toward its goal, Parliament repealed section 7AA of the Oranga Tamariki Act. The Waitangi Tribunal had found the move "rushed and arbitrary" with a "significant risk of actual harm to vulnerable tamariki." Labour, the Greens and Te Pati Maori opposed it.
Seymour directs Pharmac to drop Treaty weighting
As Associate Health Minister, David Seymour issued a letter of expectation telling drug-buying agency Pharmac to stop factoring the Treaty of Waitangi into funding decisions, saying it should serve people "based on actual need." Pharmac later disestablished its Maori advisory group.
Cabinet circular: "need, not race"
Public Service Minister Nicola Willis announced a Cabinet Office circular directing agencies to target services on the needs of all New Zealanders and to make a "strong analytical case" before using ethnicity as a proxy for need. It also scrapped Labour's 8% Maori procurement target. The circular gives effect to coalition commitments with ACT and NZ First.
Bowel screening row tests "need not race"
The Government lowered free bowel-cancer screening to age 58 for everyone, using money that had funded an earlier age-50 start for Maori and Pacific people. Dr Nina Scott of Hei Ahuru Mowai called it "institutionalised racism"; the Ministry of Health said the universal setting would prevent more cancers overall.
ACT tallies the wins, eyes 2026
Marking two years in government, ACT listed abolishing the Maori Health Authority, ending race-based waitlists, repealing section 7AA, restoring Maori-ward referendums and securing the "need, not race" directive. Its broader pledges — defining the Treaty principles and ending co-governance — remain unfinished going into 2026.
What people are saying
Sources
- ACT — Defending Equal Rights & Democracy ↗
- Beehive — Need and value at forefront of public service delivery (Nicola Willis, 13 Sep 2024) ↗
- RNZ — Seymour announces policy directive on 'need, not race' ↗
- The Spinoff — Pharmac, ACT and the Treaty of Waitangi ↗
- RNZ — Bill repealing section 7AA of the Oranga Tamariki Act passes first reading ↗
- RNZ — Bowel cancer free screening age lowered to 58, funding pulled from Maori programme ↗
- RNZ — Bowel cancer screening changes 'driven by ideology, not facts' ↗
- RNZ — How the coalition plans to replace the quickly scrapped Maori Health Authority ↗
- Waitangi Tribunal — Report on the disestablishment of Te Aka Whai Ora ↗
- Scoop / ACT — Two Years of Fixing What Matters ↗
- Otago Daily Times — Govt announces policy directive on 'need, not race' ↗
